Alison Ng Tsz Ying
A Comparative Study of Early English Consonant Development between North American and British Children: Same or Different?
Alison Ng Tsz Ying 2017-18 Term 1

Supervisor: Prof. Jette Hansen Edwards

Supervisor's Recommendation

I’d like to nominate Alison Ng, for her project ‘A comparison of early English consonant development between North American and British children.’ Alison’s project had a unique focus, one that has been underexplored in the literature on child phonological acquisition. Her study is therefore both original and significant. Alison carried out her project through a careful phonological analysis of a large amount of child language, which both requires expertise and precision. It is also extremely time-consuming. Her careful and considered analysis of the data provided Alison with interesting findings, which she interpreted against the available literature. In all tasks – project development, data collection and analysis, and project write up – Alison displayed great maturity in her research engagement. Her work is excellent.


Abstract

The comparison of the English consonants used by North American and British have often been a prevalent research topic in the field of language acquisition and accent because of their historic background and economic power. Linguists similarly found that North American and British children normally acquire all English consonants before puberty. However, study on a comparison of consonant developmental patterns from infant to toddler between the two territories had rarely been done. The purpose of this capstone is to fill in this research gap and to provide evidence on how the developmental patterns of English consonants between the North American and British infants are similar and different from the age of 12 to 36 months. This project selected the phonological transcripts of five North American and British infants, aging from 12 months to 36 months. The results demonstrated similar developmental patterns between 12 months to 18 months among all participants regardless their nationality. Nevertheless, the patterns became significantly different from 24 months to 36 months as the North American participants showed particular difficulties with the acquisition of stops, nasals and consonant clusters because of the distinctive features of the American consonant inventory.


Reflection

This capstone, I can say, is a miniature of what I have learnt from the courses of the English major. From courses on English phonology to applied linguistics, however, a question kept crawling in my mind that I couldn’t get rid of: if American and British English consonants are in ways similar and different, how would they influence and shape the early consonant developmental pattern? This question had disturbed me for long until this capstone project. Throughout the three-month research, it empowered me to conduct my own study and offer my own answer. More importantly, it became the beacon of my life that the analyses of speech patterns and their causes affirmed my aspiration of becoming a speech pathologist. I wholeheartedly thank all professors of the Department of English, especially my supervisor, Prof. Jette, for their guidance and helps throughout my life as an English major.